Quotes • Headscratchers • Playing With • Useful Notes • Analysis • Image Links • Haiku • Laconic |
---|
In Real Life, gender reassignment for a Transgender person is a lengthy process involving extensive hormone and psychological therapy. For example, in the United States, people need at least three months of therapy or "real life training" before hormones can be legally administered, and at least another year after that before genital surgery, which may itself involve a long time on a waiting list. Additionally, the physical changes brought about by hormones take several years to occur, as with puberty.
Examples of this trope disregard all or most of the above. Not only is the Easy Sex Change much faster, but the physical, psychological, and social complications are also minimized. The physical transformation is usually highly effective, resulting in Attractive Bent Gender. Not that this can't happen in Real Life, but recipients of the Easy Sex Change almost always come out looking like a Hollywood starlet or supermodel.
Sometimes accompanied by Magic Plastic Surgery (particularly when the role is played by different actors pre-op and post-op.) If you see sex change surgery that is reversed, this is another signifier of the Easy Sex Change at work. That being said, the "reversed sex change" is not completely unheard of in Real Life — see, e.g., the story of British millionaire Charles Kane, but not nearly as common as media makes it out to be. Often followed by Something's Different About You Now.
Not to be confused with Gender Bender, which involves sex changes that (usually) are even easier, and driven by magic or Applied Phlebotinum. This trope is more about idealized (occasionally highly idealized) versions of Real Life SRS.
Anime and Manga[]
- Franken Fran has a double example. Possibly justified by Fran quite frankly being crazy enough to do it, especially since she performs pretty much any surgery she thinks is warranted regardless of later psychological issues and believes "alive but in unimaginable, incurable psychological torment" to be preferable to "dead". Oddly enough, it's one of the few "happy" endings (though the couple in question is later revealed to have broken up after cheating on each other).
- Wandering Son, which treats these types of issue more seriously in general, averts this. At one point, Transgender Cool Big Sis Yuki confides to Yoshino that her mother can't forgive her because she wanted to be a girl, "wanted it so bad." Which can imply that Yuki went through all the proper processes.
- It's also showing signs with the protagonists, who are slowly transitioning (well, as much as teenagers with parents who aren't letting them go to therapists can).
- Averted in Pretty Face: Dr. Manabe insists on giving Rando a sex change (since he has a girl's face), and acts like this trope is real. Rando, on the other hand, knows better and beats the hell out of Manabe whenever he brings it up.
- Semi-averted in The Day of Revolution: Kei/Megumi's gender reassignment goes fairly easily since she's already genetically female and physically intersexed. However, everyone agreed to go through with it far too quickly and for fairly dubious reasons.
- In He's Dedicated to Roses, the main heroine briefly (but seriously) contemplates getting a sex change operation seeing how her crush is in love with her crossdressing alter-ego and she doesn't want to hurt him by letting him know she's actually a girl. Of course, this idea is quickly shot down and isn't brought up again.
- Averted in Kyou Kara Yonshimai: The surgery that the trans woman Kashiwa needs is expensive as fuck, so she has to return home and start working so she can gather enough money. When her elder sister and family breadwinner Botan leaves the house after a huge fight with her sisters, Kashiwa finds a small stash where Botan had secretly started to set apart money to help her. Understandably, Kashiwa is driven to tearsby the discovery.
- Sorcerous Stabber Orphen is set in a world with magic, but it still dodges the trope. Stephanie (formerly Stephan) did get a magical sex change, implying that this can be done without gigantic bureaucratic processes, but the circumstances surrounding the "operation" itself say otherwise — Stephanie could only access it after her male body was pretty much torn apart after a magical accident.
Comic Books[]
- Averted in The Sandman story "A Game of You"; Wanda lives as a woman and appears to be taking hormones but won't get "the operation" because she's terrified of surgery. It later comes out that she was rejected and despised by her entire family, who all want to pretend that the whole "wanting to be a girl thing" never happened. Sex change (or more accurately, gender change) appears to have been very hard for Wanda so trying to live as a man must have been even harder. After Wanda dies, she's buried as "Alvin" by the family, but her friend Barbie alters the name in the stone
Fan Fic[]
- Discussed and averted in, of all things, a The Penguins of Madagascar fic entitled "Princess"; Kowalski, the resident Mad Scientist, quite easily could give Julien male anatomy, but they decide it's a bad idea because it would raise uncomfortable questions from the humans and because Kowalski's inventions have a tendency to go horribly wrong.
- A Fire Emblem Engage Diamant/Alcryst fic featuring an FTM transgender Alcryst averts this by explicitly stating that Alcryst had his top surgery and was taking potions to aid in the transition. He's even shown being insecure about his surgery scars and filling out his underwear with a sock as a placeholder while he waited for the potions to take their course.
Film[]
- Averted in The Silence of the Lambs, when Hannibal says that the Serial Killer will probably be found to have been rejected by multiple sex reassignment clinics because he thinks he wants to be a woman when he really just hates himself.
Lecter: Our Billy hates his own identity, you see. He always has, and he thinks that makes him a transsexual. But his pathology is a thousand times more savage and more terrifying. He wants to be reborn, you see. |
- A subversion of this trope is central to the premise of the off-Broadway play and movie Hedwig and The Angry Inch. Hedwig's surgery is done with little preparation by a shady East German doctor, leaving Hedwig with the "Angry Inch" of the title.
- Invoked in the Adam Sandler version of The Longest Yard. Adam's team, the underdogs of the movie, replace someone on the guards' team's steroids with female hormone pills. Not more than two days later, said guy is bawling and weeping, supposedly acting feminine because of the hormone. To make a long story short, hormones do not work that way. A more likely outcome from suddenly taking a huge dose of estrogen would simply be getting very sick, in various "normal" ways (headache, nausea, etc.) Emotional side effects are possible, but would probably require testosterone-blocking medication to be taken at the same time.
- Possibly justified, if the loss of the steroids affected the guards' emotional equilibrium. If they'd been taking large enough doses to have ceased secreting testosterone of their own, their sudden drop in androgens might affect them far more than the estrogen did.
- In Myra Breckinridge, the character Myron Breckinridge has a sex reassignment surgery that works so well that his new persona as Myra completely convinces everyone that she's been female all along...which she should, being played by Raquel Welch (with Rex Reed as Myron who tags along as Myra's more-or-less imaginary friend).
- While not as "easy" for the patient as most examples, a dark take in The Skin I Live In is similarly unrealistic, as a surgeon does an involuntary sex change on the guy who raped his daughter. He also keeps him/her in isolation and uses him/her as a guinea pig for developing artificial skin.
- In the Italian Le Comiche 2, a man undergoes an accidental breast augmentation. After a while he gets a second accidental surgery in the form of a gender reassignement. As subvesion, the physical transformation is not highly effective, and this is close to reality since he never went through hormone therapy but just received breast implants and a vagina. This is very obvious once the protagonists cross path with her and she is discovered as odalisque in a harem, once she removes her veil she reveals that her face did not change a bit, including mustache. This doesn't prevent her to become the favorite of her master.
Literature[]
- Members of The Culture can change sex at will, although it does take several months for the changes to gradually take place. Justified, of course, because they're ridiculously advanced transhuman post-scarcity beings who can also (for example) produce a variety of drugs and chemicals from specially-tailored glands within their bodies simply by choosing to do so.
- Fairly easy sex changes (taking several months) are available to anyone who wants them in Walter Jon Williams' Aristoi, using a "nanologic" package. Another nanotech procedure allows men to experience pregnancy.
- Tanith Lee's Biting the Sun books describe an ultra-futuristic society with very easy sex and body changes. Officially, you are only supposed to change bodies once per month, but everybody flouts this rule all the time.
- In John Varley's Eight Worlds series, sex changes are so commonplace that anyone who spends their entire life as just one is considered a little weird, and population control laws are basically: "one person, one child."
- In the books Accelerando and Glass House by Charles Stross, people living in post-Acceleration times have completely mutable bodies: They can get a new body of either sex (or both, or neither) in as little as a kilosec (just under 17 minutes) — the time it takes an A-Gate to build it for them. This leads to phrases such as "I found myself in a female orthohuman body...".
- Within Lois McMaster Bujold's Vorkosigan Saga, the saga of Lady Donna’s sex change to Lord Dono shows that sex changes are relatively easy and painless with futuristic genetic technology, although Lord Dono comments that it does take time and his guy parts are still growing in. No mention of therapy is made although the character did go to a planet known for pervasive (sex) therapy. It's possible that Dono deliberately avoids mentioning any mandatory therapy since a) he is seeking public office, b) his family is not known for their mental stability, and c) on Barrayar, therapy carries a stigma of presumed violent insanity.
- The book Trans-Sister Radio has Dana (MtF), a college professor, get his entire surgery done to become a her over the summer so that she can come back in the fall as female. (Note that one is supposed to live as the other gender for a year before surgery even gets done, which Dana doesn't do.) The author seems to have sped up the process for drama, especially since Dana's girlfriend is a public school teacher and thus everyone in town objects to them.
- At one point in the book this trope is played straight, as a doctor discusses another MtF sex change (that he didn't perform) where the man's wife decided she was a lesbian so he had a sex change to stay with her, only to be then dumped because the wife decided she wasn't a lesbian after all.
- George Alec Effinger's Marid Audran series takes place in the Budayeen, a Red Light District of a 23rd century Cyberpunk Muslim/Arab city. In this setting, sex changes, while expensive, are still easy and commonplace. Also quite effective, though not quite to the point of being a true Gender Bender treatment. Attractive Bent Gender is the norm, not the exception.
- Eva Luna discusses the trope in regards to Eva's Cool Big Sis Mimi, a trans woman who's gone through pretty much every singlesteps for transition (hormonal treaments, breast implants and other plastic surgeries, etc.) save for the operation itself. She averts it at the very end: she makes research about the surgery, believes it's way too barbaric for her taste and decides against it. As a plus, her boyfriend (Da Editor Aravena) loves her just the way she is.
Live Action TV[]
- Invoked in an episode of The Love Boat where a woman assumes that a man on the cruise is traveling for a sex change operation because he has a dress in his room (among other misunderstandings) because obviously he would be traveling and living as a man right up until he gets the operation and jumps into womanhood all at once.
- Wonder Showzen: Mother Nature cuts off her own lady parts with a knife, then puts them in a bucket. She dies as a result of attempting surgery on herself. Then another puppet has sex with the bucket of bloody lady parts. It's just that kind of show.
- Nip Tuck had an episode with a MTF transperson becoming male again after realizing she really felt more comfortable being a gay male. Christian Troy does the surgery ASAP, without any of the prerequisites. Even assuming that Troy is an unscrupulous and unethical doctor, sexual reassignment surgery still doesn't work that way.
- The Psych episode "Who Ya Gonna Call" had a man with three alternate personalities: a woman who wanted to have SRS, a confused normal guy, and a psychopath who had murdered the doctor to prevent his imminent surgery, although he wasn't taking hormones or undergoing any other precursors to SRS. Somewhat averted in that there was a psychologist involved, but the SRS process as presented was heavily compressed.
- Unless the psychopath character overreacted to the mere mention of SRS.
- Averted in CSI in one episode, where they investigate the death of a woman and discover that she is a transwoman in the midst of transitioning to female, and has not yet had any genital surgery.
- The sitcom Soap had almost the perfect example of this trope. In an early story arc, Jodie (Billy Crystal) decides to have a sex change to please his boyfriend. Despite no real life experience (aside from a bit of crossdressing), no hormonal therapy, no psych evaluation, still looking like what he is (a man), he gets admitted to a hospital to have his outie turned into an innie, and they're apparently quite willing to do it. Of course, he does not go through with it.
- In the "Nobody's Perfect" episode of Karen Sisco, Karen hunts fugitive Louis DiNardo. Eventually, it turns out that Louis has had surgery to become "Lois". The timeline is a little vague, but certainly not enough time has elapsed for the requirements of ethical SRS medical treatment. While easy, the surgery is also thorough (Lois specifically mentions that she no longer has a penis, and that she "doesn't miss it"), and quite successful. While Louis is played by a male actor, Lois is played by Alexandra Billings, an Attractive Bent Gender female actress — albeit one who once was a male herself.
- Degrassi has set themselves up to sidestep this whole part of the issue by putting Adam in Grade 11 at age fifteen, meaning he's on schedule to graduate from High School and therefore the show before he turns 18 and can begin physical transitioning. They do have a history of retcons to keep popular characters around longer, however...
- ...and they've done it! Adam was retconned into a sophomore in the second half of Season 10. That was fast.
- Recently addressed (and averted) in an episode of Private Practice, where a patient is told that their procedure will have to be delayed because Sheldon suspects that although the desire for the operation is genuine, there are psychological issues that need to be addressed to ensure everything goes smoothly. He turns out to be right when the patient attempts suicide upon being given this news, and offers to help them get through these issues so she can complete the process of becoming a woman.
- In the much-derided Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode "Profit and Lace", Quark is forced to pretend to be a woman and conduct a meeting with an important Ferengi businessman (on the subject of women's rights on Ferenginar) while his mother is out of commission. Apparently, 24th-Century technology allows them to perform a complete sex change operation on him in just a few hours, and then change him back to a man the following day (presumably they kept his... male parts in bio-stasis or something).
- In the Torchwood episode "Greeks Bearing Gifts", Jack claims that he started paying closer attention to his co-workers after a male colleague began "acting strange" right before going on several weeks leave and returning as a woman named Vanessa. Since Jack only mentions this in passing, it's possible that sex changes are handled differently in the 51st century, and it's always possible that Jack is just that oblivious.
- Horribly averted in one episode of Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, where the perp is a transwoman who appears completely female due to hormone treatments but has not had genital reassignment surgery yet, and who killed her boyfriend's best friend because he found out about her transitory gender. Because she's physically male, the judge order her hormone treatments be stopped and she is placed in a men's prison, where she is brutally beaten and raped by the other inmates.
Professional Wrestling[]
- In the Japanese promotion FMW, we have the strange case of Gosaku, who underwent a sex change and became Asuza Kudo. Then she decided to get changed back, and somehow became the half-spider Biomonster DNA in the process. Japanese wrestling is weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeird.
Video Games[]
- Adventure in The Sleazy Back Alley of Kingdom of Loathing, and you may run into a clinic where you can get a sex change for 500 Meat and 1 Adventure, and be on your way the same day. Do it often enough, and you become eligible for a trophy. What's the meat for? You don't want to know. [1]
- In Saints Row 2, you can get a sex change for just five hundred dollars at the plastic surgeon. And not only is is cheap, it's instantaneous! (You can also go from white to black, or black to Hispanic, or white to Asian, skinny as a nail to morbidly obese, or just about anything else you can think of.)
- With tongue firmly in cheek, one of the fake radio ads in Grand Theft Auto San Andreas advertises this sort of thing.
- In Bioshock it is stated in an audio log by Dr. Steinman that Adam makes this easy, among other such things as race.
- Circuits Edge, the 1989 CRPG based on George Alec Effinger's Marid Audran series (see Literature, above), likewise features several characters who have had Easy Sex Changes (though it's not an in-game option for the player/Audran himself.)
Web Comics[]
- Averted and pointed out in Khaos Komix, and the author would know, from personal experience. Though the pre-transition was unusually easy, and they pass very well.
- Ditto for Venus Envy (also by a real life transsexual). Though Zoe has been on hormone treatment for months she has yet to develop any substantial breasts, and wears a padded bra instead. Plus the rest of her "equipment" is still intact, which occasionally causes problems...
- In fact back when there were jokes, the common gag was for Zoe to be hit with a ball in her new developments and her original equipment, reacting to both with realistic (and comedic) levels of pain.
- A Running Gag in College Roomies from Hell is the horrifying side businesses of the Hot Dog Man, which include "quick and effective sex-change surgery".
- Comes up a lot, sometimes subverted, sometimes played straight, in Unicorn Jelly and other works by Jennifer Diane Reitz. Interesting to note that the author, a transsexual herself, might actually qualify to an extent. She admits to having dealt with emotional and psychological problems her whole life and had to be somewhat less than truthful about this during the pre-treatment screening in order to avoid being turned down, though incorrect use of reassignment surgery due to deliberate subterfuge on the patient's part may be beyond the scope of this trope.
- Mentioned this on the discussion page, but the environment surrounding transsexuality and the associated medical procedures in the early 1980s was very very misogynistic. In order to acquire permission to receive hormones and surgery, the patient had to present a particular history — that they always felt like a woman inside, that they were attracted to men but currently sexually inactive due to not seeing themselves as gay, a number of other criteria intended to weed out lesbians, people with "masculine" (and normally well-paying) careers, people who were not perfectly "passable" and any other kind of person who did not perfectly portray the male-dominated gatekeeper community's collective image of what a woman should be. Transsexuals, of course, quickly learned what they were supposed to say and how they were supposed to act.
- Bending the truth to satisfy the decidedly un-PC standards of the 20th century medical establishment is one thing. Reitz's issues on the other hand...
- Even now (and possibly reflecting a shift too far in the right direction), the NHS won't even entertain a transman who likes men.
- Mentioned this on the discussion page, but the environment surrounding transsexuality and the associated medical procedures in the early 1980s was very very misogynistic. In order to acquire permission to receive hormones and surgery, the patient had to present a particular history — that they always felt like a woman inside, that they were attracted to men but currently sexually inactive due to not seeing themselves as gay, a number of other criteria intended to weed out lesbians, people with "masculine" (and normally well-paying) careers, people who were not perfectly "passable" and any other kind of person who did not perfectly portray the male-dominated gatekeeper community's collective image of what a woman should be. Transsexuals, of course, quickly learned what they were supposed to say and how they were supposed to act.
- Aversion in High Maintenance, a comic centering on a transgendered vigilante and her transitioning friend/sidekick. It might help that the writer is transgendered.
- In the Jet Dream Remix Comic, NATO scientists have re-engineered the bioweapon Virus-X into a viable Gender Bender. Unable to replicate the Western effort, Soviet scientists perfected the Easy Sex Change. While considered quite inferior and much more painful, this surgical process is much more widely available, and a powerful tool for the Reds in the "Cool War" to win over the world's teens.
- Ballerina Mafia has a sex change performed overnight as an April fools joke.
- One of the many possible modifications offered by GavCorps Diversity Engineering division in Schlock Mercenary.
Web Original[]
- The round robin story H! Flash had this very heavily implied to have happened to a character at the end of one of the chapters. The next writer, however, hated this trope and had "the operation" turn out to simply be exploratory surgery in preparation for the theoretically more realistic reassignment surgery to follow. The author of the previous chapter was not well pleased.
- Averted in, of all things, The Salvation War series. The character 'kitten' (small K not a typo; it's complicated) is partly inspired by someone known to the author who went through the same process herself.
Western Animation[]
- The South Park episode "Mr. Garrison's Fancy New Vagina" and THEN back again in "Eek, A Penis" just as easily.
- In the Futurama episode "Bend Her", Bender becomes a woman to cheat at the Olympics. The procedure involves changing out his male oil for female oil and snipping off his antenna. The operation also involves hitting his body with a hammer until it looks vaguely feminine. To be fair, Professor Farnsworth does give Bender some disclosure, about the danger of Bender's being "trapped forever between the already ill-defined robot sexes."
- Plus, y'know, he's a robot.
- In Aqua Teen Hunger Force Colon Cancer Movie Film For Theaters, this happened with Frylock. The fact that he clearly identified as a guy before the movie.
- Frylock also performed a sex-change operation on Carl (against his will) to prevent him from getting his dick cut off. It Seemed Like a Good Idea At the Time. Or rather, it didn't. The exact line was something like, "I have an idea, but it's not very good."
- Ripped off. Ouch. It also hurts like hell for Carl.
- Frylock also performed a sex-change operation on Carl (against his will) to prevent him from getting his dick cut off. It Seemed Like a Good Idea At the Time. Or rather, it didn't. The exact line was something like, "I have an idea, but it's not very good."
- In The Venture Brothers, Colonel Hunter Gathers' operation is remarkably superficial — he gains large breasts and (apparently) a vagina, but remains the same in every other way. The easiness of sex changes on this show is primarily demonstrated by the fact that Hunter gets a second one, revealing both to be part of a long Xanatos Gambit.
- Family Guy: In "Quagmire's Dad", the titular character goes in for surgery, and comes out a few (onscreen) minutes later looking like a mannish woman. No time needed to heal, and ready to have sex with an unknowing Brian right away!
- Ugly Americans has Callie get a sex change to get a job as New York Ambassador to Atlantis. At the end of the episode, just as suddenly as she changed into a man, she's mostly back to normal, but, in bed, Mark mentions her needing "a few more surgeries." From then on out, though, she's back to normal.
- An older episode had Mark himself transformed into looking like his roommate's ex-girlfriend, hoping to help him get over her. Unfortunately for Mark, seeing how his change was a curse that made him rapidly age until he had sex with a man, he didn't turn back so easily. Of course, the initial easiness is explained by Leonard Did It.