Lover Tug of War

"Mine!"
"Mine!"
"Stop! You're gonna dislocate my shoulders!"

Most guys would give anything to have the girl of his dreams literally want a piece of him.

But it can get painful if more than one girl wants that to happen.

Watch as each young lady in this tug of war grabs an extremity (usually an arm) and literally tries to take her man away from her rival, in a grotesquely hilarious exaggeration of wish fulfillment. Bonus Points if girls in competition shout this:

"He's mine!" "No, he's mine!"

A staple of the Harem genre of anime. The unfortunate bloke in question is effectively Made of Iron for the duration of suffering under this trope, especially when the contestants have superstrength.

This trope also shows the chivalrous side of a guy — he ~Wouldn't Hit A Girl~ even to protect himself from this trope. For this reason, a girl is rarely fought over this directly in Distaff Counterpart harems.

See A Lady on Each Arm for the less violent version of this trope.

---

Anime and Manga

• Baka to Test to Shoukanjuu
• Girls Bravo
• Higurashi no Naku Koro ni had this at least twice, between twin sisters at that.
• Maburaho
• Mahoromatic
• MM!
• Negima ...though given the size difference between Negi and his paramours (not to mention their energy level), it's more of a particularly fumble-prone football (either one) game.
• Omamori Himari
• Pandora Hearts...except the people fighting over Oz are Alice and...Gilbert.
• Ranma ½
• Rosario to Vampire
• Saber Marionette J
• Sayonara, Zetsubou-sensei
• Seto no Hanayome
• Seitokai Yakuindomo: Pictured above. Parodied in a Not What It Looks Like moment when Suzu is shocked after walking in to see Aria and Shino tugging on Tsuda's arms and shouting "Mine!". They were actually fighting over which one of them Tsuda would help carry heavy stuff for first.
• Tenchi Muyo!
• To Love Ru (Episode 14 in particular)
• Vandread
• Zero no Tsukaima
• The end of the Zelda II: The Adventure of Link manga adaptation ends with both Zeldas doing this to Link. As seen here.
• High School DxD

Comics

• Archie: Try finding some promotional art for this comic or its (non-Jughead) spinoffs that doesn't depict Betty and Veronica doing this to Archie.
• Superman: A lot of old comics, specially Lois Lane comics feature Lois Lane and Lana Lang in such a position.

Western Animation

• Jimmy Two-Shoes: Heloise and Beezy over Jimmy in "The Competition".
• In one of the earlier color episodes of Popeye, Popeye and Pluto vie for Olive Oyl's affections by pulling each of her arms in opposite directions. (Since she originated in the age of rubber-hose animation, her arms stretch to a length of about 30 feet.)
• A disturbing one in Superjail where the women from the female prison have a ball with the men, the Twins release spanish flies that drive all the women sex crazy. In one case two girls do this to the point they rip the man's arms off and start dry humping themselves with said arms.

Web Comics

• Ménage à 3: Yuki and Sonya do it to Gary here.